Buying a dog collar doesn’t seem like such a big deal. After all, it’s just a piece of leather or webbing that is adjustable and features attachment points for the dog’s leash and tags. There shouldn’t be any problem picking one out, right? While it is certainly true that choosing your dog’s collar shouldn’t be a million dollar question, it’s not as simple as running to a store and just picking up the first thing you see. You’ll need to consider comfort, design, and even preference (your dog’s as well as your own). This is why we’ve decided to “tag” the best dog collars in the market today that have a range of features you might be interested in. Ready?
Best Dog Collars Reviewed in 2017
- Best Dog Collars Reviewed in 2017
- 1. LupinePet Original Dog Collar
- 2. Soft Touch Collars
- 3. Blueberry Classic Nylon Dog Collar
- 4. GoTags Embroidered Reflective Dog Collar
- 5. Aolove Basic Classic Padded Leather Pet Collar
- 6. If It Barks Nylon Martingale Dog Collar
- 7. Coastal Pet Latigo Leather Round Collar
- 8. Coastal Pet New Earth Soy Dog Collar
- 9. PetMate America’s Legacy Camo Collar
- 10. Good Dog Company Hemp Corduroy Collar
- 11. Ruffwear Knot-a-Collar
- How to Choose a Dog Collar
1. LupinePet Original Dog Collar
When it comes to the ideal everyday dog collar, nobody does it better than LupinePet. Constructed from the highest quality jacquard nylon webbing, this collar can withstand anything and is guaranteed to last a lifetime (even if chewed). It comes in various sizes and plenty of colors as well as patterns (which are woven into the webbing for durability).
- lifetime guarantee (even if chewed)
- comes in various sizes and colors/patterns
- D-ring is welded steel and rust resistant
- some users have reported that the color bleeds when the collar is wet
- not returnable through Amazon
- Some users have reported that the largest size doesn’t fit their big dogs
2. Soft Touch CollarsDog Collars Leather
The Soft Touch Collars are true to their name. These collars are made of full grain naturally tanned genuine leather that is handmade and hand-stitched. It has sheepskin leather padding that is smooth and comfortable. Your dog’s hair definitely won’t catch on it. The brass hardware is lacquered and won’t rust. And the D-ring is conveniently located on top of the collar. Not only are these collars really stylish, they are also built for comfort and durability.
- handmade, hand-stitched leather
- rust-free brass hardware
- beautiful collar
- may be too thick for small dogs and too small for larger breeds
- scratches easily
3. Blueberry Classic Nylon Dog Collar
This collar is made from nylon fabric with high density webbing. The buckles are constructed of eco-friendly plastic while the D-ring is chrome-coated metal. This is an incredibly simple collar that’s perfect for everyday use. It doesn’t have any extra features or fancy finishes. It also doesn’t promise to last you a lifetime. But for its price, under $10, you get a really great bargain that your dog will also love
- simple design
- eco-friendly plastic buckles
- necks bigger than 26 inches probably won’t be able to use this
- may not be able to withstand chewing
- Some users have reported that the clasp kept getting unclipped
4. GoTags Embroidered Reflective Dog CollarDog Collar For Hunting
This is one collar that you’ll be able to read from a great distance. The reflective strip is sewn on and really bright. The embroidered name stands out quite clearly. The fabric is smooth and the stitches are well done. This collar is the perfect backup plan for your dog’s microchip.
- soft fabric
- bright and readable from a distance
- 60-day money back guarantee
- some big dogs have been able to snap the plastic buckle
- the collar has to be fully extended to show the entire stitching (otherwise part of the information will be covered)
- reflective strip can get scratched off
5. Aolove Basic Classic Padded Leather Pet Collar
If you want a genuine leather collar but can’t justify spending more than $25 on your dog’s collar, then Aolove’s Classic Padded Leather Collar is for you. While it isn’t at par with Soft Touch’s leather collar, it is still made of high quality leather that’s soft and durable. The hardware is nickel-plated and the D-ring is heavy duty.
- not easily scratched
- durable, soft leather
- attractive look
- smallest size may still be too big for some small dogs and puppies
- Some consumers have reported that the threading starts to come out after a few months
- Metal ring tends to tarnish after a few months
6. If It Barks Nylon Martingale Dog CollarDog Collar to Control Pulling
A Martingale collar is specifically designed for dogs that pull on the leash, ensuring that they won’t slide out of their collar when they bolt after something they see. This handmade collar is constructed using two loops of thin nylon webbing (in the USA) that tightens when pulled. But the pressure is distributed evenly around your dog’s neck so you don’t have to worry about hurting your dog when this happens. And the bonus? You can order a custom size to ensure that the collar will fit your dog’s neck perfectly.
- can withstand a lot of wear and tear
- non-slip design gives you better control of your dog
- lifetime warranty
- the width of the collar (1.5 inches) may be too big for small dogs
- not for dogs with fine hair (too stiff)
7. Coastal Pet Latigo Leather Round Collar
A genuine full top grain leather collar at an affordable price, Coastal Pet’s Latigo Leather Collar is simple, stylish, and sturdy. The leather is soft yet durable with an attractive brown color. While it has a very basic design (no bells and whistles here), it definitely does the job.
- made of real full top grain leather in a rich brown color
- comfortable and soft on the dog’s hair and skin
- sizing is wrong
- not as thick as other leather collars on our list
- D-ring is not heavy duty or large enough for both tags and a leash
8. Coastal Pet New Earth Soy Dog Collar
We have another favorite from Coastal Pet and this one is quite unique. The New Earth Soy Dog Collar is exactly what it says. It is made from soy fibers, a natural byproduct from food manufacturing. Not only is it an eco-friendly choice, this collar is incredibly soft and flexible. It is also quite thin that you won’t have a problem drying it out after washing. Despite its softness and flexibility, the New Earth Soy Dog Collar is very durable. It definitely holds up well.
- eco-friendly choice
- soft and flexible
- very affordable
- collar may slip off when used on dogs that pull
- Collar is a bit stretchy
- Dog can choke on the collar when chewing it
9. PetMate America’s Legacy Camo Collar
Love military dogs? Here’s a collar that honors their work and sacrifice. PetMate’s America’s Legacy collars come in four different camouflage “patterns” for you to choose from – Army, Air Force, Marines, or Navy. The collar is sold with a set of dog tags and part of the proceeds are donated to the US War Dogs Association. Aside from all the good it does in supporting our military dogs, this collar is solidly built and will withstand wear and tear.
- supports military K-9s
- comes with dog tags
- made out of sturdy nylon
- color of the Marine Corp camo is a little off
- collar loosens if the dog pulls a lot
- Buckle is a bit flimsy; easily opened by a rambunctious dog
10. Good Dog Company Hemp Corduroy CollarDog Collar for Sensitive Skin
An eco-friendly collar for an eco-friendly dog and owner. Aside from being green, this hemp collar is strong and durable. This hypoallergenic collar is perfect for dogs with a nylon allergy. The clasp mechanism is a bit stiff which can be a positive or a negative. If you have a dog that has a knack for unbuckling his collar, you’ll love this feature. Those with arthritis won’t. And while corduroy isn’t exactly stylish, you might be surprised on how good it looks on your dog.
- machine wash and dry-able
- stiff clasp mechanism
- collar may be too wide for some very small dogs
- tag loop is located right next to the buckle
11. Ruffwear Knot-a-Collar
Obviously, this is a collar for a dog who likes a bit of rough play. Okay, a lot of rough play. The ruggedness of the design is unique and definitely appealing to an outdoor type of owner. The collar comes with sliding fisherman knots so you can personally adjust the fit to your dog’s neck. It has a reflective trim that you’ll be able to see in low-light conditions. And it has a silicone tag silencer!
- unique design
- customized fit
- reflective trim
- A bit expensive
- Awkward to put on and off
- The knots slip when the dog is a puller
How to Choose a Dog Collar
Choosing a dog collar shouldn’t be so difficult. After all, it’s just a collar. Or is it? Not only will this collar help you keep your dog on a leash while walking, it can keep your dog’s identification with him (aside from the microchip, of course) so you can be assured that he’ll be returned to you if he gets lost. Naturally, there are other factors to consider as well. The size of your dog, his/her level of playfulness, his/her sensitivity, comfort, and even style. With so many options to be found online and in store, we decided to help you out so you don’t get overwhelmed.
What is the right size for your dog?
The wrong sized collar could mean problems for you and your dog. Too tight and it will harm your dog. Too large and he’ll just slip through. So, how do you know which size to buy? You’ll need to measure your dog’s neck using a cloth measuring tape. Generally, it is recommended that you are able to slip 2 fingers inside the collar when placed around your dog’s neck. For a more precise measurement, here’s a breakdown from Petful.com:
- small breeds (less than 10 pounds) – plus 1 inch to the measurement
- medium-sized dogs – plus 2 inches
- large breeds (over 80 pounds) – plus 3 inches
What about the width of the collar?
It is recommended that you choose a wide collar for stronger dogs because it lessens the pressure on the neck. But small breeds will feel uncomfortable with a wide, thick collar since they tend to weigh a lot. In general, 1 1/2 inches is good for both large and small breeds.
How well-behaved is your dog?
Be honest. Is your dog a puller? Is he ready to bolt at a moment’s notice as soon as he spies a squirrel or anything really? Then you need a Martingale collar, one that limits his movement whenever he pulls. One good example of this is If It Barks Nylon Martingale Dog Collar.
What material is best?
This is really a matter of preference. Some dogs are allergic to nylon which is the most common material used in dog collars. Also, nylon tends to stink after awhile. If your dog is sensitive (and your nose is as well), you can opt for a hypoallergenic collar such as the Good Dog Company Hemp Corduroy Collar or Coastal Pet New Earth Soy Dog Collar. Leather is a elegant choice. The Soft Touch Collars is one of the most popular on Amazon because it offers durability, comfort, and style. Some collars offer reflective coating which ensures that you’ll be able to see your dog even at a great distance or in low-light settings. Some examples are the GoTags Embroidered Reflective Dog Collar and the Ruffwear Knot-a-Collar.