Toaster ovens are incredibly useful appliances, even for those who don’t like toasting bread. It’s come a long way from reheating cold slices of pizza. Today’s toaster ovens countertop microwaves or convection ovens are a great addition in any kitchen. It not only toasts and reheats food; this multipurpose appliance can cook meals that will rival those that came from a full-size conventional oven. Of course, these modern appliances come in various shapes and sizes as well as a dizzying amount of features. There’s no question that there’s one that suits you and your family’s needs to a T. The only problem is finding it. To help you out, we did our research and tested a lot of toaster ovens. Below are 10 Best Toaster Ovens that we loved.
Top 10 Toaster Ovens Of 2018 Reviewed
1. Breville BOV800XL Smart OvenBest Toaster Oven With Convection
The Breville Smart Oven may be small compared to a conventional one but it isn’t less powerful. This convection oven can toast, reheat, bake, broil, and roast a variety of foods evenly. Want to cook a whole chicken? It can. How about a 13-inch pizza? It can do that too. The reason it can do a lot of things is that of the Element IQ functions which basically adjusts the five sophisticated heating elements inside the oven for efficient cooking. Because it is also a convection oven, it not only speeds up cooking but ensures the food is cooked evenly.
Other highlights are its intuitive surface and easy-to-read display, and the fact that it comes with several accessories. While the Smart Oven does have a lot of features (a laundry list too long for this short review), it does have some drawbacks. One, it has a large footprint measuring 18.5×16.25×11.25 inches. Two, it is expensive. And three, there are some durability issues; some users have reported their ovens breaking down after 2 to 6 years. Relatively long life but not long enough at this price.
- Cooks efficiently and evenly
- Large capacity
- Easy to use and clean
- Large footprint
- Durability issues
2. Oster Large Digital Countertop Convection Toaster OvenBest Toaster Oven For Pizza
If the budget is a bit tight but you need an extra large toaster oven in your kitchen, then this large digital convection oven from Oster is exactly what you’re looking for. It has the capacity to cook 6 pieces of toasts or a 12-inch pizza. It even has enough space for cooking thick roasts. The digital control panel includes several presets such as Bake, Convection Bake, Broil, Toast, Pizza, Defrost and Warm. The timer goes all the way to 90 minutes and the oven comes with an auto shut-off feature.
And we love how bright the light is inside. The better to see your goodies as they cook. However, the convection fan is loud. Also, it’s a bit frustrating that the default number in the timer is 30 minutes. Having to press the + or – button repeatedly just to use this oven for a couple of minutes can get old, real fast. Also, despite the large inner space, you won’t be able to fit a 9×13 pan inside if it has handles.
- Bright internal light
- Lots of presets
- The convection fan is loud
- The default time is 30 minutes
- Won’t fit 9×13 pans with handles
3. Panasonic NB-G110PW Flash Xpress Toaster OvenBest Toaster Oven For Toast
If you lack the space on your countertop for one of the big toaster ovens on our list, then you’re the best bet is going with the Panasonic Flash Xpress Toaster Oven. Just like its name implies, this oven makes toast impressively fast. Even better, it adjusts cooking time automatically when it detects increased temperature such as what happens when you toast multiple batches of bread. While it only takes up a small amount of space (approximately cubic feet in volume), it can accommodate two slices of pizza or four pieces of bread. Also, this little baby does a good job of baking too.
While cakes are out of the question, you can bake cookies with this unit. Other great things with this oven to take note of include 6-menu illustrated preset buttons, instant heating (no preheating required), a digital timer, and precise temperature control. However, the timer is maxed out at 25 minutes so you need to keep resetting the timer if you plan on cooking or baking something in the oven for longer than that. The included toaster pan is nothing to be desired. And it can get extremely hot so be careful, especially if you have little ones around.
- No preheating required
- Toasts fast and evenly
- Very easy to use
- Poor quality toaster pan
- Max time in timer is 25 minutes
- Can get very hot
4. Breville Compact Smart OvenBest Toaster Oven For The Small Kitchen
If the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven is too much for you, then you can opt for his little brother instead. The Breville BOV650XL Compact Smart Oven has a lot of the same features including Element IQ, the easy-to-read display, and the intuitive controls. Unlike its big brother, this one only comes with 8 cooking functions (no Warm function).
And it can only fit 4 pieces of toast, a 12-inch pizza, a 6-cup muffin tray, or a whole chicken. Plus, this is not a convection oven. But it is less expensive compared to the Smart Oven (though it is still expensive compared to its compact competitors) and it takes up the less real estate. One thing we dislike about this oven is that it doesn’t have an internal light which makes it difficult to watch your food.
- Element IQ technology
- Intuitive controls
- Small footprint
- Still expensive
- Not a convection oven
- No internal light
5. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven with Roll-Top DoorBest Toaster Oven For Baking Bread
The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven is a convection and toaster oven with three functions – bake, broil, and toast. It features a 30-minute timer with a stay on set, a removable crumb tray, easy-to-use controls, and two rack positions. The oven comes with a baking pan and bake rack. Now, what sets this oven apart from other toaster ovens is its Roll-Top Door that you won’t be seeing anywhere else. This makes food easy to reach and frees up countertop space in front of the oven.
Another thing that sets this oven apart is that you can opt between bake and convection so you can create delicious cakes and desserts without worrying about your batter shifting or splattering inside the oven because of the fan. However, it does get really hot on the outside which can be dangerous if you have unsupervised kids in the kitchen. However, the oven is not well-insulated so it can get very hot. Don’t let kids near it. The included bake pan is easily stained and hard to clean. The door is not removable so it is also hard to clean.
- Roll-top door
- Convection option
- Stay-on setting
- Can get really hot
- Hard to clean
- Poor quality bake pan
6. Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven BroilerBest Toaster Oven For Broiling
The Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven Broiler is different from your regular toaster oven. It features touchpad controls instead of the usual knobs and dials. It has a stainless steel bar and side grips, giving it a sleek, commercial look. With a 0.6 cubic foot capacity, you can easily fit 6 slices of bread inside. The functions include bake, broil, toast, convection, reheat, and defrost.
The unit cooks food beautifully. But it tends to run hot and you can end up burning your fingers if it brushes the top edge of the door. To clean the crumb tray, you need to access it through the back which is super inconvenient. And there is no internal light so it can be hard to check on your food while it’s cooking.
- Large capacity
- Commercial look
- Electronic Touchpads
- Runs very hot; fingers can get burned
- Crumb tray access is from the back
- No internal light
7. Oster 4-Slice Toaster OvenBest Toaster Oven For RV
Unlike the other Oster Toaster oven on our list, this one can only accommodate up to 2 ½ slices. But that just means that it’s perfect for small kitchens and even smaller countertops. This oven comes with a temperature range of up to 450 degrees, a broil option, toast settings, and a 30-minute timer with a stay on set.
The adjustable rack has two positions and the crumb tray is removable and easy to clean. However, the surface of the toaster gets really hot. The tray doesn’t catch all the crumbs and it’s hard to take out which can make cleaning the oven a bit less convenient. And it toasts bread pretty fast so keep an eye on it. For the price though, it can’t be beaten.
- For singles
- Toast, broil, and bake functions
- Very affordable
- Poor quality crumb tray
- The surface can get really hot
- Toasts bread fast; can get burned easily
8. KitchenAid 12-inch Convection Digital Countertop OvenBest Toaster Oven For Bagels
This stainless steel convection countertop oven from KitchenAid is the perfect choice for people who want to take the guesswork out of cooking. This unit comes with 9 preset functions – bake, pizza, Asado roast, broil, keep warm, reheat, cookie, bagel, and toast. The oven has a large capacity, enough to cook 2 12-inch pizzas or cornish hens at the same time.
It comes with a 12″ non-stick multipurpose pan, a 12″ broiling rack, a cooling rack, and a non-stick drip tray. As an added bonus, this unit comes with a 1-year hassle-free replacement warranty. However, it doesn’t come with an internal light. The controls aren’t as intuitive as they look. And it’s expensive.
- 1-year replacement warranty
- Large capacity
- Lots of preset functions
- No internal light
- Not easy to use
9. Cuisinart TOB-260N1Best Toaster Oven Without Nonstick Coating
This is another convection oven from Cuisinart but a different beast altogether. It’s much bigger – able to fit as many as 9 slices of bread. It comes with a ceramic pizza stone, two racks, a baking pan, and a broiling tray. It has four slots for the racks. And it features 10 preset cooking functions as well as a dual mode function that allows you to program to different cooking modes to run consecutively like baking lasagna then keeping it warm until everyone is ready to eat.
Plus, it has a +30 option that enables you to add 30 seconds to any cooking function. There are even two convection settings, the speed one allows you to cook without preheating. While this oven performs well, the build quality isn’t the best. The print on the buttons wears off pretty easily. As large as it is, it won’t fit a 9×13 inch pan with handles. And it can get very hot on the top and sides.
- Dual mode function
- +30 Option
- Two convection settings
- Won’t fit a 9×13 inch pan with handles
- Can get very hot
- Print on buttons wear off quickly
10. BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster OvenBest Toaster Oven For College Dorm
This small toaster from Black + Decker features 4 different cook functions – bake, broil, toast, and warm, a temperature range of up to 450 degrees, and a 30-minute timer dial that has a stay on set. While it is quite small, it can easily fit a 9-inch pizza or 4 slices of bread which are perfect for a small kitchen. It does get hot on the outside so be careful what you put beside it. Also, it can be difficult to see which part of the knob has the pointing feature. Plus, it takes some trial and error to figure out how to get your toast just right. But for the price, it’s a decent basic toaster oven.
- Small footprint
- 4 cook functions
- Hard to read the knobs right
- Learning curve when toasting bread
- Can get really hot on the top and sides
Toaster Oven Buying Guide
Toaster ovens are a perfect addition to any kitchen, big or small. It can do a lot of the work of a traditional oven, sometimes even faster, serve as a primary oven in small houses or those in warm climates, and can even be used as a secondary oven for those who want to prepare large meals.
Toaster ovens may be small (compared to regular ovens, anyway) but they sure can be mighty powerful. You can use them to toast and reheat food as well as bake and broil meals for you and your family.
Obviously, if you’re reading this guide, then you’ve been searching for the perfect toaster oven for your kitchen. And we understand your dilemma. There are a lot of options in the market, varying sizes, a wide range of features. It can be quite difficult to narrow down which one you should bring home. Well, this guide should help you in your decision-making process. We’re going to break down just what exactly your toaster oven should be able to do and what has just added perks that you can do without.
Types of Toaster Ovens
Basic Toaster Ovens
This type of toaster oven is the typical one you see in your local store. It won’t have a lot of the bells and whistles. Usually, it has a limited amount of cook functions – bake, broil, and toast. And, despite the lack of convection technology, the best ones can still cook evenly and consistently. They also cook much faster than the conventional oven because they preheat faster.
Convection Toaster Ovens
This type of toaster oven, obviously, uses convection to make it cook more efficiently – faster than just the basic toaster oven. Some convection toaster ovens are so versatile (lots of cook functions) that they can easily replace large ovens in the kitchen. However, they tend to be more expensive than the basic type.
How much food do you plan to cook in your oven?
You need to determine how much bread you want to toast at once or how many slices of pizza you want to reheat. You need to think about how many people you want to be able to feed. If you have a large family, you’ll need a toaster oven with a large capacity like the Cuisinart TOB-260N1 which can accommodate up to 9 slices of bread at a time. If you’re only cooking for one or two people, you may be happy with something small like the Breville Compact Smart Oven. You should also consider what type of food you want to cook inside that oven. For example, even if it’s just two of you, you’re going to need a bigger capacity if you plan on cooking something like roast chicken or beef roast.
What kind of food do you plan to be cooking?
Aside from capacity, the type of food you’ll be cooking will also affect your choice of features. Some toaster ovens like the KitchenAid 12-inch Convection Digital Countertop Oven come with preset cook functions for certain foods like cookies and pizza which takes the guesswork out of cooking. Some convection toaster ovens like the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door allow you to switch the convection option off when baking bread and cakes that may not fare well with a fan blowing on them. If you plan on just using heating up pizza and leftovers, you can stick with something basic like the Panasonic NB-G110PW Flash Xpress Toaster Oven.
Let’s talk countertop space
Your toaster oven is going to be sitting on top of your counter so you need to consider how much space you have to spare. If you don’t plan on leaving it on your counter, you still need to consider its footprint in terms of storage space. Some toaster ovens are pretty big like the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven while others such as the BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster Oven are small. While pictures and reviews can give you a better idea of capacity, you need the measurements to truly assess its size.
Other factors to consider
If you want versatility in your toaster oven, you’re going to want to look for a wide temperature range. This allows you to easily toast bread at a low temp or bake pizza which requires a significant amount of heat. The Oster 4-Slice Toaster Oven can go as high as 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
Having a lot of features is all well and good. But you also need to make sure that they don’t complicate things for you. Yes, you can always fall back on the good ole manual but you still want to be able to operate the unit when cooking the simple stuff. That said, you should look for intuitive controls, easy to use even for non-oven users. The Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven, for example, has very easy-to-understand controls. You don’t have to be a genius or a chef to operate it.
Naturally, you’ll want to be able to see how your food is coming along. Most toaster ovens have a clear glass door enabling you to peek right inside it. However, this can become clouded and dirty over time. You may want to look for a toaster oven with an internal light like the Oster Large Digital Countertop Convection Toaster Oven.
All toaster ovens come with a timer as this allows you to cook your food without burning it. Some models will have preset functions that already have set cook times such as a 30-minute to defrost. Most models will have a 30-minute timer while other will have up to 60 or 90 minutes. Some models such as the Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door will feature a stay-on option that allows you to keep the oven on indefinitely for foods that require a very long cooking time. More importantly, you need to make sure that setting the timer is as simple as turning the knob.
Trays and Racks
Most toaster ovens will come with a removable crumb tray, a baking pan, and a rack. What you need to check is how easy these accessories are to pull out of the oven, especially when it’s still hot. The removable crumb tray is of great importance because it allows you to clean the inside of your oven with minimal effort. Make sure that it’s easy to pull out and that it pulls out from the front. Also, you may want to consider looking for an oven with an adjustable rack and more than just one slot as this gives you more flexibility when cooking and baking.
Toaster ovens can get pretty hot fast which is why they’re so handy to have around. But that also means that there’s a risk of accidental fires. Look for a toaster oven that will automatically turn off once the timer runs out to reduce this risk.